Big Church, Same Games

D-Now – Week 6

Did you ever attend a D-Now? It was called a Discipleship Now Weekend…which some could argue is an oxymoron, but I digress…

It’s one weekend, a handful of host homes, small groups crammed into somebody’s living room, a few big rally sessions with a guest speaker brought in just for the occasion.

By Sunday night we were exhausted, maybe still a little sunburned or gross from the previous days activity, and usually convinced something life-altering had happened.

And maybe something had. I don’t want to take that away from any potential good that can come from these things.

But we called the weekend “discipleship now” when discipleship is not a weekend and it doesn’t happen now.

I guess we just didn’t have a better word for it, so the name was used and it stuck. And an entire generation grew up associating discipleship with an event you scheduled a few times a year instead of a way you lived every day in between.

This whole series has been about that same mistake, scaled up.

We took a set of tools built for a temporary, high-intensity weekend and made them the permanent plan for the church.

Entertainment instead of formation.

Emotional peaks instead of steady faith.

Separated rooms instead of a whole family.

Charismatic communicators promoted faster than they could be spiritually formed.

Every single one of these things started with good intention and none of them were ever supposed to supplant what was already there. And yet they did.

So here’s a genuine question: If a D-Now weekend isn’t discipleship, then what is?

it doesn’t happen fast or publicly

Discipleship, the actual kind, goes almost embarrassingly unnoticed.

It appears as a phone call at nine at night because someone’s marriage is falling apart and they don’t know who else to call.

It’s experienced when the same six people show up to the same living room every Sunday night for six years, watch each other’s kids grow up, and watch each other fail and repent and fail again.

It’s an elder in the faith, who has buried their spouse, teaching a twenty-five-year-old how to grieve well, because nobody else in the twenty-five-year-old’s life has ever had to.

It is being known well enough that someone can tell you the hard truth and you leave the room because you’ve gone through enough life with them to love and trust them.

None of that happens on a stage. None of that happens in a year, or two, or even three. 

It doesn’t qualify for a highlight reel. It cannot be measured by a headcount. It will never trend on social media.

And it also cannot be produced in a single weekend, no matter how good the speaker, band, small groups, or activities are.

what needs to change to make disciples

If we believe discipleship is the main task of the church, and I do, it means some important things for how we build a church.

It means the metric can’t be attendance. It has to be something slower and harder to measure, like: Are people actually maturing? Are they less selfish, more patient, more honest than they were three years ago? Are they sacrificing more of their time, talents and treasures than they were before?

Nobody puts these kinds of things on a dashboard, because you can’t. You have to actually know people to know the answers.

It means leadership development has to include the wilderness years, not just the glamorous years. The decades of sitting with hurting people, of struggling to get things established, of learning to shepherd people slower than you’d like to go if it was just you.

We cannot keep promoting the twenty-five-year-old who’s great at Youth Sunday straight into leading the whole church and be surprised when the whole church starts to feel like Youth Sunday.

It also means we have to actually mix the ages back together. Not one joint service a year for optics, but real, ongoing, uncomfortable proximity between the sixty-year-old and the sixteen-year-old. Because that’s the only way either of them ever gets discipled by anyone outside their own stage of life.

And finally it means we have to be willing to build a church that is, most days, genuinely ordinary. Not because ordinary is holy for its own sake, but because faithfulness on an ordinary day, with nothing riding on it and no one watching, is the actual substance of the thing we’ve been chasing by going to mountaintops for decades.

a longer, slower weekend

I still think about those D-Now weekends sometimes. The exhaustion, the closing worship, the way it felt like something had shifted.

Something had. It just didn’t last, because a weekend can’t replace what only years can establish.

Discipleship was never supposed to be a single high-intensity event we scheduled a few times a year. It was supposed to be an everyday sort of faithfulness – a Monday morning prayer text group, an ordinary phone call to ask for wisdom, a decades-long, unglamorous, mostly invisible work of actually knowing and being known.

D-Now was never wrong as a weekend. It only became wrong when it turned into the whole discipleship plan.

This post is a part of the “Big Church, Same Games” series. The next post is “Mission Trip.”

About the author

Drew Anderson

Son. Brother. Husband. Father. Friend. Mentor. Spiritual Director. Consultant. Coach. Student. Communicator. Organizer.

Add Comment

Click here to post a comment

Book Available

Promotion for Book "Faith is..."